Retention Champions by loan count — Indiana

Retention champions in Indiana this year, ranked by loan count. Powered by ChatMMI — the only fully conversational AI experience for mortgage and real estate data.

As of May 18, 2026, the top 3 include Carrie Johnston (Winterwood Mortgage Group, LLC, NMLS #60874), Thomas Faille (Ixonia Bank, NMLS #543277), and Kyle O'Keefe (CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #158077).

Updated · Mortgage origination data has varying lag based on county public recording speeds.

Retention Champions by loan count — Indiana — top 50
Rank Loan officer LO NMLS Lender / Broker Lender NMLS Location Retained Volume Retained Loans Retention Rate
#1 Carrie Johnston 60874 Winterwood Mortgage Group, LLC 122171 Greenwood, IN $7.1M 26 81.3%
#2 Thomas Faille 543277 Ixonia Bank 423065 Brookfield, WI $6.6M 24 72.7%
#3 Kyle O'Keefe 158077 CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC 3029 Fishers, IN $4.9M 18 72.0%
#4 Tiffany McIntosh 414040 Fifth Third Bank, National Association 403245 Fort Wayne, IN $3.3M 14 46.7%
#4 Mark Kuchik 139563 CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC 3029 Carmel, IN $4.8M 14 73.7%
#6 Tyler Cartmel 7540 American Neighborhood Mortgage Acceptance Company LLC 338923 — $3.8M 13 44.8%
#6 Garrett Litke 2110271 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Valparaiso, IN $4.8M 13 86.7%
#8 Jason Everette 1208653 CMG Mortgage, Inc. 1820 West Lafayette, IN $2.8M 12 44.4%
#8 Michelle Jacinto 209470 Direct Mortgage Loans, LLC 832799 Saint John, IN $3.0M 12 44.4%
#10 Kevin Fortriede 1179707 Union Savings Bank 446047 Fort Wayne, IN $3.3M 11 84.6%
#10 Tracy Harding 172796 MJW Financial LLC 199907 Indianapolis, IN $3.6M 11 68.8%
#10 Nicholas Boucher 1064332 Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. 141868 Fort Wayne, IN $3.9M 11 55.0%
#13 Jamie Freeze 1580657 Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. 141868 Fort Wayne, IN $2.9M 10 90.9%
#13 Chad Fallis 292827 CrossCountry Mortgage, LLC 3029 Carmel, IN $3.4M 10 58.8%
#13 William Losh 555765 FORUM Credit Union 469848 Fishers, IN $2.7M 10 52.6%
#13 Richard Davis 1866591 Sullivan Home Loans, LLC 2539836 Bedford, IN $3.2M 10 71.4%
#13 Craig thompson 278106 Union Home Mortgage Corp. 2229 Middletown, IN $1.9M 10 71.4%
#13 Ashley Ingram 1327713 Bedford Federal Savings Bank 402489 Bedford, IN $3.6M 10 83.3%
#19 Chad Crile 1562657 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Crown Point, IN $3.8M 9 56.3%
#20 Leanne Murray 525350 Union Home Mortgage Corp. 2229 Crown Point, IN $1.8M 8 40.0%
#20 Eric Flores 149587 NATIONS LENDING CORPORATION 32416 Fort Wayne, IN $2.2M 8 61.5%
#20 Michael Frantz 110316 Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. 141868 Indianapolis, IN $3.3M 8 57.1%
#20 Alyssa Jay 1683887 Three Rivers Federal Credit Union 556303 Fort Wayne, IN $925K 8 50.0%
#20 Alana Foster 1326520 Bedford Federal Savings Bank 402489 Bedford, IN $1.6M 8 50.0%
#20 Jeremy Flatter 555769 FORUM Credit Union 469848 Fishers, IN $2.2M 8 47.1%
#20 RYAN EBERHARDT 260832 DIAMOND RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE CORPORATION 186805 Valparaiso, IN $2.0M 8 42.1%
#20 Seth Bennett 938187 V.I.P. Mortgage, Inc. 145502 Fort Wayne, IN $2.1M 8 44.4%
#20 Jon Knight 175955 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Carmel, IN $3.7M 8 44.4%
#20 Phillip Lillge 967760 Flat Branch Mortgage, Inc. 224149 Fishers, IN $2.8M 8 42.1%
#20 Jodona Young 20787 KeyBank National Association 399797 Anderson, IN $1.4M 8 80.0%
#31 Larry Dickey 163931 Ruoff Mortgage Company, Inc. 141868 Fort Wayne, IN $2.1M 7 36.8%
#31 Bethanna Beatty 746252 First Financial Bank 619717 Richmond, IN $627K 7 70.0%
#31 Crystal Wilson 137742 CME Lending Group LLC 1248883 Chesterton, IN $1.9M 7 41.2%
#31 Nichole Beem 546614 Regions Bank 174490 Frankfort, IN $1.8M 7 58.3%
#31 Heather Neuner 1226172 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Greenwood, IN $2.1M 7 58.3%
#31 Andrew Reising 17259 Mortgage Masters of Indiana, Inc. 126673 Evansville, IN $1.7M 7 41.2%
#31 Renee Miller 1897324 Three Rivers Federal Credit Union 556303 Richmond, IN $700K 7 63.6%
#38 Mike Eason 434071 Indiana Members Credit Union 402492 Indianapolis, IN $1.4M 6 46.2%
#38 Michelle Adrian 1014947 FORUM Credit Union 469848 Fishers, IN $1.3M 6 37.5%
#38 Bradley Smith 139830 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Fishers, IN $2.1M 6 21.4%
#38 JENNIFER JURS 209256 American Pacific Mortgage Corporation 1850 Demotte, IN $2.1M 6 46.2%
#38 Michael Waters 150593 Union Home Mortgage Corp. 2229 Valparaiso, IN $1.7M 6 60.0%
#38 John LeRose 225701 Guaranteed Rate, Inc. 2611 Dyer, IN $1.1M 6 46.2%
#38 Nickolas McIntosh 1374946 Fifth Third Bank, National Association 403245 Fort Wayne, IN $1.5M 6 54.5%
#38 Bradley Niccum 1642106 NCL, LLC 139952 Indianapolis, IN $1.5M 6 40.0%
#38 Austin Smith 262571 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation 2289 Greenwood, IN $2.5M 6 31.6%
#38 Brian Brent 368334 GVC Mortgage, Inc. 2334 Whiteland, IN $1.6M 6 40.0%
#38 Mark Lewin 525366 Guild Mortgage Company LLC 3274 Fishers, IN $1.7M 6 42.9%
#49 Austin Logue 655234 Peoples Bank 512564 Munster, IN $2.7M 5 50.0%
#49 Gregory Thomas 138839 Stockton Mortgage Corporation 8259 Fort Wayne, IN $1.1M 5 25.0%

Other rankings in Indiana

Same ranking, all states

Try /lo or /lender to look up a profile, or /me for yours.